How Your Temperament Affects Your Money Mindset

Have you ever won­dered why some people are natural savers while oth­ers can’t resist a good splurge? Or why some prefer detailed budgets while others make financial decisions on the fly? It all comes down to temperament and how you communicate.

Your temperament is the wiring that drives your natural thoughts, behaviors, and responses—including how you handle money. The key to wise financial decisions isn’t just a better budget; it’s better self-aware­ness. Understanding your temper­ament can help you recognize why you make certain money decisions and how to manage finances in a way that aligns with your strengths.

But here’s something even more important—each tem­perament also speaks a unique language, has specific strengths and weaknesses, and is motivated by innate needs. When it comes to money, knowing your own temper­ament and understanding others can help you make better financial decisions, reduce stress, and com­municate more effectively.

IDENTIFY YOUR TEMPERAMENT IN MONEY MANAGEMENT

Below is a simple tool to help you begin identifying your temperament and how it affects your money habits. After reviewing, take a moment and ask yourself: Which of these descriptions sounds most like me?

YELLOW

SPEAKS

• The Language of People & Fun
• Extrovert & People-Oriented

ATTRIBUTES

• APPROVAL
• ACCEPTANCE
• ATTENTION
• AFFECTION

RED

 SPEAKS

• The Language of Power & Control
• Extrovert & Task-Oriented

ATTRIBUTES

• LOYALTY
• SENSE OF CONTROL
• APPRECIATION
• CREDIT FOR WORK

GREEN

 SPEAKS

• The Language of Calm & Harmony
• Introvert & People-Oriented

ATTRIBUTES

• HARMONY
• FEELING OF WORTH
• LACK OF STRESS
• RESPECT

BLUE

SPEAKS

• The Language of Perfection & Order
• Introvert & Task-Oriented

ATTRIBUTES

• SAFETY
• SENSITIVITY
• SUPPORT
• SPACE & SILENCE

WHY THIS MATTERS: REAL-LIFE SCENARIOS

Let’s explore how each tempera­ment handles money in everyday situations and how their language, strengths, and innate needs influ­ence their financial behaviors.

THE YELLOW TEMPERAMENT

Scenario: Lisa, a Yellow, walks into a store for one thing but leaves with five. She sees a sale and thinks, “This is a great deal! I deserve a treat.” Explanation: Yellows are driven by excitement and experiences. They love spending money on fun things and making memories, but they may struggle with impulse control. Since two of their innate needs are attention and approval, they may also spend to impress or bring joy to others. Therefore, they benefit from setting a spending limit while still allowing space for enjoyment.

THE RED TEMPERAMENT

Scenario: Mark, a Red, is in charge of his household finances and expects everyone to follow his plan. He doesn’t understand why his partner wants to discuss purchases. Explanation: Reds are decisive and results-driven. They see mon­ey as a tool for success but may come across as too controlling. Since their innate needs include a sense of control and appreciation, they may struggle when others challenge their financial decisions. They benefit from considering other perspectives and making room for collaboration.

THE BLUE TEMPERAMENT

Scenario: David, a Blue, wants to buy a new laptop. He spends weeks researching, comparing features, and reading reviews but still can’t make a decision.

Explanation: Blues prioritize security and planning. They are great at sticking to a budget but may stress over making the “perfect” financial decision. Their innate needs for safety and sup­port mean they need reassurance they are making wise financial choices. They need to remind themselves that progress is bet­ter than perfection.

THE GREEN TEMPERAMENT

Scenario: Rachel, a Green, has been meaning to look at her budget but keeps putting it off. When her spouse brings up finances, she says, “It’s fine. I don’t want to argue.”

Explanation: Greens avoid money stress and confrontation. They prefer “simplicity” but may ignore financial problems until they become unavoidable. Since their innate need is harmony, they may avoid tough financial discussions altogether. A gentle approach and small, manageable steps help them stay engaged.

Now that you’ve identified how your temperament influences money de­cisions, the next step is understand­ing how you communicate about money with others—and how to have healthier money conversations with the people in your life!

HOW YOUR TEMPERAMENT AFFECTS MONEY CONVERSATIONS

Your words have the power to shape other people’s lives. Every day, with every word, you can build up or tear down. The Apostle Paul knew this, so when he wrote a letter to a church he had founded years earlier in Ephesus, Paul reminded them to watch their words. His advice:

“Do not let any unwholesome talk come out of your mouths, but only what is helpful for building others up according to their needs, that it may benefit those who listen” (Ephesians 4:29, NIV).

This verse is an excellent communication outline for us. The word “let” means that we have a choice in the words we speak. Every word you use is a word you chose. The word “unwholesome” doesn’t mean curse words. It means anything that is detrimental to the well-being of another. We are to speak only what is “helpful” for “building others up” “according to their needs.” If you don’t know the innate needs of each tempera­ment, how can you speak in a way that builds them up accordingly? When we speak this way, it “bene­fit[s] all who listen.”

HOW THE FOUR TEMPERAMENTS TALK ABOUT MONEY

Let’s start with an overview of how each temperament generally talks about money.

YELLOW Talks freely, sees money as fun, may avoid serious conversations. Be clear but encouraging—help them see the bigger picture while still keeping it light. RED Direct, strategic, may come across as controlling. Respect their logic but remind them that financial decisions impact rela­tionships, not just outcomes. BLUE Focuses on details, plans, and security; can overanalyze or worry. Acknowledge their need for structure but encourage flexibility and emotional reassurance. GREEN Avoids conflict, goes with the flow, may not engage in money talks. Ask open-ended questions and give them space to process without pressure. PRACTICAL STEPS FOR BETTER MONEY CONVERSATIONS: REAL-LIFE SCENARIOS

Now that you know how each temperament talks about money, let’s run through a few examples of how this could play out in real life and a few tips to help you communicate with this color better.

TALKING TO A YELLOW

Scenario: You sit down to discuss budgeting, but your Yellow partner changes the subject or starts telling a funny story instead. They interrupt or become distracted.

How to Communicate: Speak their “language” of fun and optimism. Instead of saying, “We need to talk about our spending problem,” validate them by saying something like, “I know it’s not always fun to talk about money issues.” Then try speaking their language: “Let’s set some exciting financial goals together!”

TALKING TO A RED

Scenario: Your Red spouse makes all the financial decisions and tells you, “This is the best plan; just trust me.”

How to Communicate: Respect their need for a sense of control and efficiency but remind them that money affects relationships. Instead of saying, “Stop being so controlling,” validate them by saying something like, “You’re so good at seeing the end result.” Then say, “I trust your instincts. Let’s make the call together, so we’re both on board.”

TALKING TO A BLUE

Scenario: Your Blue family member wants every detail about financial planning and keeps ask­ing for more spreadsheets.

How to Communicate: Recognize that their need for structure and safety helps them avoid overanalyzing. Instead of overwhelming them with too many options and saying, “You’re overcomplicating this,” validate them by saying something like, “You are so good at looking at all the details before making a final decision.” Then say, “Let’s make a strong plan, but let’s also allow room for adjustments.”

TALKING TO A GREEN

Scenario: Your Green friend avoids the money conversation and says, “Let’s just do whatever works for you.”

How to Communicate: Respect their desire for harmony and avoid pressuring them. Instead of saying, “You need to be more involved,” validate them by saying something like, “Your opinion in this matter is important.” And then say, “Let’s go over this to­gether at your pace.”

Mastering the communication skills of validating, complementing, and speaking their language is critical in effective communication—and understanding temperaments gives you the framework for success!

---

If this resonates with you, there’s so much more to learn! In her workbook, I Said This, You Heard That 2025 Edition, Kathleen walks you through a full assessment to help you understand your temperament. This article was published in our Faithful Steward magazine, a quarterly publication filled with encouraging stories, biblical teaching, and practical tools to help you grow as a wise and joyful giver. If you'd like to begin receiving Faithful Steward, consider becoming a FaithFi partner.